Best Pizza in Ohio: Must-Try Pizzerias Across the State
Discover Ohio’s best pizzerias and learn how long is pizza good for in the fridge. Try these top spots!
1. Lucarelli’s
Lucarelli’s has carved out a reputation in Ohio’s pizza scene by sticking to simple, straightforward quality and honest flavors. Locals say Lucarelli’s is their go-to spot when hunting for the best pizza in Ohio—there’s a reason new faces are always joining the regular crowd. Their pizzas come out hot, crisp at the edge, and with just the right amount of melted cheese.
What really stands out is how fresh their toppings taste. You don’t get soggy slices here; instead, it’s a chew that hits you with smoky pepperoni or earthy mushrooms every time. Pricing feels fair, and you can grab a table with friends or get a box to go.
Here’s what makes Lucarelli’s pop up on so many top pizza lists:
- Classic hand-tossed crust that holds its own
- Flexible menu for picky eaters and adventurous types alike
- Consistently friendly service, whether you order in or take out
| Popular Pizza Choices | Price (Medium Pie) | Toppings Highlight |
| The Lucarelli Original | $14.99 | Pepperoni, Sausage |
| Veggie Delight | $13.99 | Mushrooms, Peppers |
| Double Cheese | $12.99 | Extra Mozzarella |
Stopping by Lucarelli’s is always worth it—time slows down, the food’s good, and even when the place is packed, staff make you feel welcome.
If you’re interested in more than just food and are looking into local businesses (maybe you’re curious about business brokers, automotive business brokers, or even searching for “internet business for sale”), the atmosphere at Lucarelli’s can remind you what makes a truly local spot stand out. Not every pizzeria on the list has that same community vibe—that’s where Lucarelli’s shines.
2. Dewey’s Pizza
Dewey’s Pizza is one of those places where you walk in and you know you’re about to eat something good. Started in Ohio, Dewey’s has grown a lot but somehow keeps that neighborhood feel. The menu is full of both classic and slightly odd combos—the kind that makes you rethink your usual order.
The WOW factor is their crust: light, bubbly edges and the right kind of chewy. It actually holds up under all those toppings, which is more than I can say for some places.
Some of the favorites to try if you go:
- The Green Lantern (loaded with garlic, fresh veggies, and goat cheese)
- Edgar Allan Poe (if you’re into sun-dried tomatoes and olives)
- The classic pepperoni, because you need to taste how they do the basics
Here’s a quick look at what to expect:
| Pizza Type | Size Options | Price Range |
| Specialty (e.g. Edgar Allan Poe) | 11″, 13″, 17″ | $13-$27 |
| Create Your Own | 11″, 13″, 17″ | $10-$25 |
| Calzones | One size | $10-$14 |
People often hang out at Dewey’s after work or bring their families on weekends. Actually, I even overheard someone talking about using business brokers to find a location for their next shop. That made me realize how pizza places like Dewey’s can attract different folks—families, couples, even folks researching internet business for sale ideas or asking questions about automotive business brokers over dinner.
If you’re trying to convince a picky group to agree on dinner, Dewey’s might be your best shot in Ohio. The variety and consistent quality make it a winner every time.
3. Tommy’s Pizza
Tommy’s Pizza is a name you’ll hear all over Columbus when the topic of best pizza comes up. The crust here is that perfect balance of crisp and chewy, and their pepperoni cups are something pretty special. The shop’s history goes way back, and a lot of locals have grown up grabbing slices after high school games. Tommy’s has this way of making a plain cheese pie seem exciting—no fancy toppings needed.
If you’re weighing your options for dinner or just passing through Columbus, here’s what makes Tommy’s stand out:
- Their signature thin crust is always cut into squares, perfect for sharing (or not).
- They keep their menu simple—lots of old-school recipes without any over-the-top combinations.
- There’s a relaxed, low-key vibe, so it’s good for a casual meal with friends or family.
| Popular Pizza Choices | Size Options | Notable Features |
| Classic Pepperoni | Small, Large | Crisp crust, spicy cups |
| Mushroom and Sausage | Small, Large | Homemade sausage |
| Plain Cheese | Small, Large | Rich tomato sauce |
You can’t really go wrong with any order, but if you’re torn, just grab a large pepperoni and call it a day. There’s a reason Tommy’s is always mentioned whenever people start talking about local pizza favorites.
Whenever I visit, Tommy’s feels like a throwback—you’re not getting internet business for sale vibes or any flashy, modern stuff. Just pizza done right. Funny thing, a business for sale broker once told me places like Tommy’s are goldmines because of loyal customers. Whether you’re an automotive business brokers fan looking for a post-deal meal, or just a hungry regular, Tommy’s is easy to love.
4. Harvest Pizzeria
Nestled in Columbus, Harvest Pizzeria has built a huge following for its fresh ingredients and seasonal toppings. The menu is all about making pizza feel special but still super approachable. Their wood-fired pies use lots of local produce, and honestly, you can taste the difference. For anyone who always wants to know how long is pizza good for in the fridge, Harvest’s leftovers reheat well—usually up to four days if you store them right.
- Creative pies like the Spicy Yuma and Ohio Double Bacon keep regulars coming back.
- Veggie options are just as popular as the meat ones, which is rare in most spots.
- The dough has this crisp edge but also stays chewy in the middle. It’s really nice and not too heavy.
Here’s how some customers rate their most popular pizzas:
| Pizza Name | Cheese (1–5) | Crust (1–5) | Sauce (1–5) |
| Spicy Yuma | 5 | 4 | 5 |
| Ohio Double Bacon | 4 | 5 | 4 |
| Pineapple Sriracha | 4 | 4 | 5 |
You’ll probably hear locals chatting about small businesses growing up in Columbus, everything from internet business for sale opportunities to business brokers in the food scene, including a few stories about business for sale brokers helping out pizza shops in the area. Even automotive business brokers sometimes grab pies here post-meeting—it’s that good.
The thing about Harvest is you get those fancy toppings without the stiff atmosphere. It’s more like your friend’s kitchen than a pricey eatery.
5. Vero Pizza Napoletana
If you find yourself craving authentic Neapolitan-style pizza in Ohio, Vero Pizza Napoletana is a place locals talk about constantly. Their pizzas cook in less than two minutes in a wood-fired oven, giving the crust the perfect combination of char and chew.
Here’s what makes Vero stand out:
- Dough is made fresh daily and left to ferment for maximum flavor
- San Marzano tomato sauce and imported Italian cheeses are a staple
- Toppings are straightforward – think fresh basil, house-made sausage, and bright veggies
- Open kitchen so you can watch the pizza being made
The menu is tight and focused, and you won’t find any crazy creations—just classic pies. There’s a strong sense of community among the regulars, with lots of folks even talking shop between bites (I overheard someone chatting about business brokers and an interesting internet business for sale last time I was there). Automotive business brokers might want to take a cue from Vero’s straightforward approach.
| Specialty Pie | Price |
| Margherita | $14 |
| Diavola | $16 |
| Salsiccia e Funghi | $17 |
Vero is really laid back—no fuss, just delicious pizza in a neighborhood spot where everyone seems to know each other. If you like simple, high-quality ingredients, this is a must-try.
6. Mama Santa’s
If you ask locals in Cleveland about their favorite pizza joint, there’s a good chance you’ll hear them mention Mama Santa’s. This spot is practically a legend in Little Italy, serving pies that keep regulars coming back year after year.
Mama Santa’s is all about those old-school Italian roots—think crisp thin crust, homemade sauce, and real, stretchy mozzarella. The prices are friendly, and portions always feel generous. While some people talk up the spaghetti or meatballs, the pizza steals the show. It’s nothing fancy, just well-baked crust, a little semolina dust, and toppings that taste extra fresh.
- A cozy, family-run spot with a loyal following
- Known for its sausage and cheese pizza – simple, but so good
- Dine-in is casual, but the pizza travels well if you’re taking it home
| Specialty Pie | Sauce | Cheese | Slice Price |
| Sausage & Cheese | Red | Mozzarella | $3.50 |
| White Pizza | Garlic | Ricotta/Mozz | $4.00 |
| Veggie | Red | Mozzarella | $3.75 |
This isn’t just pizza. For a lot of folks, a slice at Mama Santa’s reminds them of family get-togethers and easy weekends. You don’t get that feeling at just any chain.
While waiting for your pizza, conversations sometimes turn to the local scene—like people talking about business brokers, business for sale brokers, or even someone asking about finding the best automotive business brokers in the neighborhood. One regular even mentioned they saw an ad for an internet business for sale on a napkin there once!
It’s the type of place that keeps you coming back because it feels familiar and real, reminding you why pizza is such a comfort food for so many in Ohio.
7. Gatto’s Pizza
Gatto’s Pizza has earned a reputation in Columbus for serving up classic, no-nonsense pizza that people really crave. Their thin, crackly crust and sweet sauce combination keep loyal fans coming back for decades. You can taste the simplicity, and frankly, that’s part of its charm. Walking in, the décor’s straight out of an older era, and you almost expect to see families who’ve been regulars for generations crowding around giant cheese pizzas and Coke pitchers.
Here are a few things that make Gatto’s Pizza stand out:
- They cut their pies into squares, a Columbus trademark.
- The pepperoni is always crispy—never greasy.
- Prices are fair, so it’s an easy go-to for groups or family hangouts.
| Pizza Style | Price (Large) | Specialty Item |
| Thin Crust | $16.99 | Pepperoni & Banana Peppers |
| Classic Cheese | $14.99 | Crisp, oven-baked cheese |
| Loaded Deluxe | $19.99 | All toppings included |
If you’re in town and thinking about business brokers, or maybe shopping around for business for sale brokers because there’s an internet business for sale in the area, don’t skip a stop at Gatto’s. You never know—their welcoming vibe makes it easy to trade stories with locals (including those who work with automotive business brokers) over a hot, fresh pizza. It’s just that kind of place.
Gatto’s isn’t flashy, but it’s real, and that counts for a lot when you just want a reliably great pie in Ohio.
8. Rubino’s Pizza
Rubino’s Pizza sits quietly in Bexley, but anyone who grew up even close to Columbus knows there’s nothing quiet about their reputation for standout thin-crust pizza. The old-school vibe—worn floors, fixed booths, and that familiar oilpaper under every pie—makes it feel like stepping into a snapshot from decades ago.
Here’s what makes Rubino’s stand out:
- All pizzas are hand-tossed and cooked on stone, giving the crust that signature crisp bite.
- Toppings never overwhelm; instead, you get balanced flavors where cheese, sauce, and meats meld perfectly.
- Prices are fair, portions are huge, and service is always friendly but never rushed.
| Item | Small | Large |
| Cheese Pizza | $8.50 | $13.00 |
| Pepperoni Pizza | $9.00 | $14.00 |
| Sausage Pizza | $9.00 | $14.00 |
It’s interesting: even business brokers and the folks who work around Bexley know this is a lunch spot to sneak away to—some claim it’s cited in talks with automotive business brokers as an example of how family-run spots keep beating national chains! If you’re scoping out internet business for sale listings late into the night, this is the kind of pizza you want within delivery range.
Some regulars eat here every week, swearing by the distinct taste that never seems to change even as new pizza places open all around.
Rubino’s isn’t fancy. It’s not pretending to be. And sometimes, you just want a classic, honest pizza where the only thing that matters is how good that next bite is. If you haven’t checked it out, put it on your list—no matter what side of town you call home.
9. Angelo’s Pizza
Some folks swear by this spot on the west side of Cleveland. Angelo’s Pizza wins people over with its chewy crust, expertly browned cheese, and piles of toppings. They’ve been around since the late 70s, holding down Madison Avenue with lines out the door on weekends.
Here’s what stands out at Angelo’s:
- Crust that’s soft on the inside and golden on the outside
- Toppings stacked high, especially pepperoni and sausage
- Famous for their white pizza and a respectable vegan menu
If you’re curious about the different types of pies, here’s a quick look:
| Pizza Type | Description | Fan Favorite? |
| Traditional Round | Thick, chewy, golden | Yes |
| White Pizza | Ricotta and fresh basil | Yes |
| Gluten-Free | Offers an option for everyone | Growing |
Angelo’s is also a common meeting spot for local groups and small business owners—it’s not rare to overhear folks talking with business brokers about the next big move, whether it’s about business for sale brokers or someone with an eye on the next internet business for sale. The place even gets a few regulars from local automotive business brokers grabbing a slice after work.
Angelo’s has that hometown feel: you can show up in jeans, grab a huge pizza, and know you’re getting the same thing every time. The vibe is busy but friendly, and the pizza comes out hot, even if you have to wait a bit.
10. Adriatico’s and more
Adriatico’s has a straight-up loyal following in Ohio, especially near college campuses. The thick, chewy crust and the spicy pepperoni are legends in their own right, and people will argue about the right edge-to-sauce ratio all day. If you’re looking for a pizza spot that feels like home, Adriatico’s is one of those places.
Here’s why folks keep coming back:
- Oversized Sicilian-style pies with a crispy crust
- Generous amount of cheese and toppings—no skimping
- Late hours, perfect for a midnight bite or post-game slice
But honestly, Ohio has even more than just Adriatico’s if you’re on the hunt for classic pizza. Try these other standout spots:
- Terita’s – Old-school charm with a killer pepperoni pizza
- Flyers Pizza – Popular for their thick crust and bold sauce
- Cassano’s – Dayton classic with thin crust fans
| Pizzeria | City | Specialty |
| Adriatico’s | Columbus | Thick crust, pepperoni |
| Terita’s | Columbus | Classic pepperoni |
| Flyers Pizza | Multiple | Thick crust pizzas |
| Cassano’s | Dayton | Thin crust, simple pies |
Sometimes, the best memories are just late nights at a small table, friends all around, and a pie right in the middle. If you’re ever trying to buy or sell a pizza shop, you might even run into business brokers or business for sale brokers specializing in the food industry. You’ll even bump into automotive business brokers or see an internet business for sale, but nothing quite compares to owning a spot where people come hungry and leave happy.
Ohio’s pizza scene isn’t just about flavor—it’s about community. Try any of these, and you’ll taste what everyone’s been talking about for years.
Wrapping Up the Pizza Hunt
So, that’s my take on some of the best pizza spots in Ohio. There are so many places out there, and honestly, you could spend months just trying them all. Each pizzeria has its own thing going on—some go heavy on the cheese, others have that perfect crispy crust, and a few just surprise you with something totally different. If you love pizza, Ohio is a great place to explore. Next time you’re hungry, maybe try one of these spots. Who knows, you might find your new favorite slice. And if I missed your go-to place, let me know—I’m always up for another pizza adventure.
